Do startups suffer from sharing the lead?
Corporate research says that when several people lead together, you get power struggles, knowledge hiding and slow decisions. My co-author Viktor and I wanted to know if that holds in startups, where co-founders share the lead from day one.
The short version: mostly it doesn't. The one real cost is slower decisions, and almost every founder said it's worth it.
Guess first
Each of these is a known risk of shared leadership in established companies. Did it show up among our 11 startup co-founders? Make your guess, then see what they told us.
- Slower decisions 8 of 11 · High, but seen as an investment
"Yes, very much. It is one of our biggest issues. That we aren't as efficient as I would have wanted." Co-founder 9
- Nobody owns the task 3 of 11 · Low, mostly small tasks
"Not big cases or big topics … we will have these small cracks where something is falling in between two chairs." Co-founder 5
- Role stress 3 of 11 · Low, under time pressure
"When you have a really tight schedule … you do tend to forget things." Co-founder 8
- Losing motivation to lead 2 of 11 · Low, early adjustment only
"If you are used to having the final say and now you don't … sometimes in the beginning I felt a little not that motivated." Co-founder 5
- Knowledge hiding 2 of 11 · Very low
"Then I'll sit on this information right now. It is not in order to gain an advantage … We have more important things to do." Co-founder 11
- Power struggles 0 of 11 · None
"Be open to change, be open to the fact that someone might know better than you … then it works really well." Co-founder 7
Why startups are different
The dark sides in the corporate research all come from the same place: what's best for me doesn't match what's best for the team. A manager protecting their territory has a career to think about.
In a young startup that gap almost disappears. The company might not exist next year, titles are mostly "for investors", and everyone is betting on the same outcome. We called this venture-first unity: a low-ego way of working where survival of the company beats personal status.
So frameworks built on clear lines between the individual, the leader and the team don't fit. In a startup one co-founder is often all three before lunch.
"It's like you're playing in a band. We don't need to discuss if you're playing the guitar or I'm playing the drums."
How we got there
An exploratory, qualitative study. We didn't tell the founders we were looking for negative consequences, so they wouldn't go looking for problems to please us.
- 3incubators and accelerators in Lund and Copenhagen opened doors
- 5new ventures, 1 to 5 years old, in tech, energy and software
- 11co-founders interviewed one by one, in person or on video
- 10 hof recorded interviews, transcribed word by word
- 6phases of thematic analysis (Braun and Clarke), coded by both of us separately
In their words
Co-founders are numbered at random, so nobody can be matched to their company.
"(My co-founder) and I quit our jobs and decided to go for it." Co-founder 6
"Of course in the beginning that is something that you decide to do." Co-founder 2
"(Co-founder) is the brake, (co-founder) is the accelerator and I'm the clutch." Co-founder 8
"You put on the hat that is needed that particular day." Co-founder 1
"I'm happy that I don't have to have responsibility of everything." Co-founder 2
"If I said that we should do this and it became bad … we carry it together. If it becomes good, then it was we who did it." Co-founder 11
"Who has the lead isn't relevant, it's what will be best, what will increase our chances of succeeding." Co-founder 7
"We have a mutual goal that we are working towards and the internal prestige does not exist." Co-founder 1
What founders can do
- Split the work by expertise that doesn't overlap. When each founder is clearly better at something, the lead moves to whoever knows most, and there's nothing to fight over.
- Set shared goals early, then keep doing it. Weekly or monthly. Different pictures of where the company is in five years were a real source of friction.
- Keep egos low and trust high. It lets founders hand off decisions, share the stress and step back without losing face.
What this doesn't show
Eleven founders from five ventures in one region is a small sample, and ten of the eleven were men. Everything is self-reported, and founders who are still together are probably the ones who get along. We'd love to see the same questions asked to teams of four or more, where cliques might start to form.